Buying & replacing
Garage door materials: what's best for you?
Each material has trade-offs in cost, looks and upkeep. Here's a plain comparison to help you choose.
Steel
Strong, affordable and available in almost any style. Insulated steel adds stiffness and keeps the garage cooler. Watch for dents and touch up scratches to prevent rust.
Wood
Beautiful, custom and naturally insulating. Wood needs refinishing every few years in the Texas sun and is usually the heaviest option.
Vinyl
Dent-resistant, rust-proof and nearly maintenance-free. The color runs all the way through, so it won't peel.
Wood on steel and fiberglass
Wood-on-steel puts a real wood face on a steel frame, giving you wood looks with less upkeep. Fiberglass can mimic wood grain and resists rust and rot.
Weight matters
Wood and wood-on-steel doors are heavier, so they need stronger springs and sometimes a more powerful opener. Steel and vinyl are lighter and easier on the hardware.
Insulation ratings
R-value measures how well a door resists heat transfer. For an attached garage in North Texas, an insulated door with a higher R-value keeps the garage and the rooms next to it more comfortable through the summer.
About the author
Paul RichmondPaul Richmond owns Garage Door Solutions, the family business he bought from his father, Curt Richmond. He writes our homeowner guides from the questions our technicians answer every day across Collin, Grayson and Fannin counties. Garage Door Solutions is a division of American Service Center, serving North Texas since 1985.
Meet our team →
Amarr
C.H.I.
Clopay
Genie
LiftMaster
Linear
Marantec
Wayne Dalton